More Than Just Food: What to Look for in a Wedding Caterer

Sharing:

Wedding catering in Toronto is fairly interesting in that there are a lot of different styles of caterers, there are a lot of different sizes of caterers, there are a lot of different capabilities of caterers, and each one does a different thing.

Some of them specialize in doing really great barbecue buffets. Some of them specialize in doing authentic South Asian cuisine, for example. Some of them specialize in doing very inexpensive buffet-type service where they can just drop off food hot and ready. And that’s all they do. They drop off delicious food, but they don’t necessarily engage the staff or hire the rentals that you need.

How do I prepare to talk to a wedding caterer?

The first thing to do if you’re looking in Toronto for a wedding caterer is to figure out a venue. The venue, even more than basically anything else at the wedding, is going to have the most impact on catering cost.
The reason for this is that a Toronto wedding venue might have a full commercial kitchen that you can use, whereas another one may have an empty room where you have to bring in all the rentals of tables, and prep surfaces, and stove tops, and ovens in order to make the food hot. So, beware if a venue looks really inexpensive. Ask yourself why do they come with a whole kitchen? Or is my caterer going to have to spend $1,500 renting equipment? Do they come apart from kitchen equipment with other useful and valuable items?
For example, if you’re having 120-person wedding and you get this beautiful venue, but they don’t come with chairs, if you want to have somewhere to sit for your guests, you or your caterer is going to have to rent in chairs to the venue. Depending on the look you want, this can be very inexpensive, if you get a plastic folding chair, for example, at about $6 a piece or $5 a piece; but if you want a decent looking chair for your wedding day that isn’t a plastic folding chair, realistically people are looking at sort of $10 to $12 for renting a dining chair. So, beware at suspiciously inexpensive venues because there may be other hidden costs that drive up the catering. Not because food is more expensive at one venue or another, but because at one venue we need to rent in 120 chairs at a dollar a piece, adding $1,000 to the rentals, and we need to rent in an oven. So, picking a venue is the first and most important thing.
And as far as what to look for in a venue, I’d suggest the more stuff your venue comes with, the more it’s going to have a positive effect from your point of view on the catering cost. So look for a venue with a commercial kitchen. Look for a venue with tables and chairs. Look for a venue that include linens and napkins and use of a kitchen, and weigh those costs in comparison to what may be a more economical venue. Maybe the venue is $2,000 cheaper, but you’re going to have to spend $3,000 to get the same amount of equipment and chairs at venue A.

What information should I give my caterer before the wedding day?

I mentioned before that all the different caterers in Toronto do different things. But not all the caterers are necessarily capable of doing a lot of different things. What do I mean by that?

You can find a South Asian caterer, you can find a Central American caterer, you can find a Chinese caterer. But if you’re looking for a wedding caterer in Toronto, that means you live in the most multicultural and most diverse city in the world. Chances are if you’re looking for a caterer for your wedding, probably you’re not both from the same cultural background. It’s likely that you’re from different backgrounds and want to feature different types of flavours and ingredients and even vibes at the wedding.

And so it’s really important when you’re looking for a caterer, depending on the venue, you have to find one who’s capable of doing customized menus, capable of putting together and curating a multicultural wedding menu, and has the knowledge, the experience, and the team to be able to effectively blend those ingredients, those flavours, those dishes, those traditions into a fusion that works. And not a fusion that is confusion.

Building on that information, what you should give your caterer is going to depend on the caterer. If you want to have a barbecue wedding, you’re going to have to tell your caterer what your favourite kind of barbecue is. Is it Tennessee style? Is it St. Louis style? Is it Texas style? If you’re looking for a South Asian caterer, you’re going to have to talk about what’s going to be on your menu, because South Asia is a huge place. There are dozens and dozens of different culinary traditions. Do you want Bangla cuisine? Do you want a totally vegetarian menu? What kind of vegetarian is it? Are eggs okay? Are eggs not okay? It really depends. So think about these things before you talk to your caterer.

Further building on that, if you’re looking for something that blends more than one culinary tradition, really think about talking to your caterer. Because without talking to them over the phone, over Zoom, or better yet, in person, like in the olden days when people used to meet face to face, you’re really not going to get a sense for what they know and what they can do and how much you can trust them. And so talking to them is a really great first step, not just to manage your expectations, but so that the caterer can manage theirs as well and more effectively. Learn what you’re looking for, what a menu is to you, whether you need a custom menu, whether you’re fine with a package menu.

And in some cases, a package menu is fine. If you and your partner are both from Goa, you can go and find a South Asian caterer and easily get a Goa menu out of a package. And that’s great. But what if one of you is Peruvian, one of you is Chinese? Then that’s more difficult because there aren’t any caterers that I know of that are Peruvian and Chinese.

And this is where a caterer like en Ville comes in. We’re a full-service caterer, but we don’t feature any set menus or pre-designed menus. And that’s by design because we feel that being in the most multicultural city in the world, we want to be able to create menus that reflect who these people are.

All of us, we grew up eating Pho and tacos and empanadas and fufu one day to the next. We’ve been so lucky to have been brought up in a city that features so many different options from so many different cuisines. And so not only do you have your own cuisine that you grew up with in your household, thanks to your parents and your aunties and your grandma, but we’re also so lucky to have been brought up in such a multicultural city where we can get so many different things. So try and find a caterer that’s reflective of Toronto and Toronto’s famous multicultural aspects and is capable of doing multicultural wedding catering.

Other information to give to my caterer before the wedding day: come to your meeting prepared with basic information. If you have a tentative timeline for the day, come with that already because caterers are going to need to include in their invoice things like staff hours for bartenders and servers and chefs. And to calculate that accurately, we need to know what time they’re going to be starting, what time they’re going to be ending.

So consider coming to your meeting prepared with timing information, with information like, are you having your ceremony on site, is it happening off site? Do you want to use an outside vendor for anything? For example, maybe you want to have a South Asian chai station as the welcome drink. Is your caterer capable of preparing chai? Do you have a chai vendor that you want to bring in and set up a chai wallah station to serve to all of your guests?

As much information as possible is always helpful, but if you don’t have information, come prepared to the meeting with questions you should be asking the caterer. Are you a full service caterer? Do you do all inclusive catering? Can you arrange all of the rental equipment, all of the service staff, beverages, alcohol, food, late night snacks, transportation, accommodation, entertainment, AV, DJ services and an officiant and an master of ceremonies? And some caterers can and some caterers can’t.

Depending on how much work you are willing to do yourself, that may help guide your decision as to whether you want a full service caterer or a caterer who offers more basic levels of services.

Sharing is caring!
(416) 533-8800 LET’S CONNECT